Hi Dave,

No, the correct value is pointopoint or ptp, I have tried type ptp and broadcast but still same.

The neighbor won't up.

I don't know if it's a bug or not but I have tried very basic configuration from wiki page and still same.

Thank you

Best regards,
David S.
------------------------------------------------

e.  david@zeromail.us
w.  pnyet.web.id

p. 087881216110

On Sat, Dec 31, 2016 at 8:06 AM, dave seddon <dave.seddon.ca@gmail.com> wrote:

Just a guess " pointopoint" -> " pointtopoint"

On Dec 30, 2016 5:04 PM, "David S." < david@zeromail.us> wrote:

Dear All,

I have trouble to establish ospf on BIRD 1.6.3 using FreeBSD 11 amd64, here is my topology and BIRD configuration:

router-a ------ router-b (directly connected use cat6)

router-a: 10.22.40.17/30

router-b: 10.22.40.18/30

bird.conf in router-a

        router id 10.5.16.1;

        debug all;

        import filter ospf_in_routerb;

        export filter ospf_out_routerb;

        tick 2;

        area 0 {

           interface "bge0" {

                stub;

                cost 5;

                hello 10; retransmit 2; wait 10; dead 40;

                type pointopoint;

                };

           networks {

                103.22.40.16/30;

                };

           interface "*" {

                cost 1000;

                stub;

                };

        };

}

bird.conf in routerb

        router id 10.5.16.2;

        debug all;

        import filter ospf_in_routera;

        export filter ospf_out_routera;

        tick 2;

        area 0 {

           interface "bge0" {

                stub;

                cost 5;

                hello 10; retransmit 2; wait 10; dead 40;

                type pointopoint;

                };

           networks {

                103.22.40.16/30;

                };

           interface "*" {

                cost 1000;

                stub;

                };

        };

}

I found the following error message from bird.log:

2016-12-31 07:52:38 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:52:43 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:52:48 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:52:53 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:52:57 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:53:03 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:53:07 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:53:13 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:53:18 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:53:22 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:53:27 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

2016-12-31 07:53:28 <ERR> ospf1: Socket error on bge0: Invalid argument

Show ospf:

bird> show ospf

ospf1:

RFC1583 compatibility: disabled

Stub router: No

RT scheduler tick: 2

Number of areas: 1

Number of LSAs in DB:   260

        Area: 0.0.0.0 (0) [BACKBONE]

                Stub:   No

                NSSA:   No

                Transit:        No

                Number of interfaces:   25

                Number of neighbors:    0

                Number of adjacent neighbors:   0

                Area networks:

                          10.22.40.16/30      Advertise

bird> show protocols all ospf1

name     proto    table    state  since       info

ospf1    OSPF     master   up     07:53:28    Alone

  Router ID:      10.8.60.1

  Preference:     150

  Input filter:   ospf_in_routerb

  Output filter:  ospf_out_routerb

  Routes:         25 imported, 259 exported, 0 preferred

  Route change stats:     received   rejected   filtered    ignored   accepted

    Import updates:             25          0          0          0         25

    Import withdraws:            0          0        ---          0          0

    Export updates:         630587          0     630328        ---        259

    Export withdraws:           22        ---        ---        ---          0

Why ospf neighbor can't established?

I'm new to ospf and really need help.

Thank you

Best regards,
David S.
------------------------------ ------------------

e.  david@zeromail.us
w.  pnyet.web.id