Hello, there is a discrepancy between doc and parser. Please try s/providers/provider/; Sorry for the inconvenience. We'll fix this in the next version. Maria On 6 January 2025 08:40:36 CET, Jelle Luteijn via Bird-users <bird-users@network.cz> wrote:

Hoi,

Yesterday I tried to implement the validation of ASPA in my router filters. I have generated the ASPA table via the mainline version of RPKI-Client, docker image rpki/rpki-client:edge to be precise. For Bird I use version 2.16 provided from https://pkg.labs.nic.cz/.

When loading the bird configuration with the new table I get the following error: /etc/bird/rpki2/bird:642145:17 syntax error, unexpected PROVIDERS this line is: route aspa 945 providers 174, 6461, 6939, 7018, 9002, 32097, 401111; (full table provided below)

I tested this yesterday with Job Snijders. He told me that when bird 2.16 is compiled from source it does work, and he was able to replicate the issue with the packages from the repository.

I prefer not to compile the software myself and to use vendor provided packages.

Does somebody know what’s going on?

Regards, Jelle Luteijn

---

define force_roa_table_update = 1736147917; aspa table ASPAS;

#ROAs are removed from snippet due to size

protocol static { aspa { table ASPAS; };

route aspa 945 providers 174, 6461, 6939, 7018, 9002, 32097, 401111; route aspa 970 providers 54874; route aspa 11358 providers 835, 924, 6939, 20473, 34927; route aspa 13852 providers 6939, 20473, 34927, 52025, 209533; route aspa 15562 providers 2914, 8283, 51088, 206238; route aspa 16909 providers 20473, 21738, 34927, 47272, 53356, 53667, 152900, 209643, 212477; route aspa 19330 providers 393577; route aspa 21957 providers 970; route aspa 28584 providers 28605; route aspa 33733 providers 174, 6939, 12186, 47787, 200454; route aspa 40544 providers 924, 6939, 12186, 52025; route aspa 41720 providers 174, 1299, 9002, 50877, 60068, 203446, 212508; route aspa 44324 providers 945, 955, 1299, 3204, 6939, 7720, 8772, 8849, 15353, 18041, 20473, 29632, 32595, 34465, 34927, 41051, 43426, 47272, 48266, 51087, 53667, 53808, 59105, 59538, 61112, 134823, 134835, 138997, 139317, 150452, 151364, 199545, 199765, 200105, 206499, 207656, 207841, 209554, 209735, 212483, 213856; route aspa 44355 providers 207841; route aspa 47272 providers 174, 835, 924, 1299, 6830, 6939, 20473, 21738, 25759, 34927, 35133, 41051, 48605, 50391, 50917, 52025, 52210, 58057, 210667, 212514, 212895; route aspa 47689 providers 924, 1299, 6939, 21738, 34465, 34549, 34927, 395823; route aspa 48070 providers 174, 1299; route aspa 48606 providers 30893, 54681, 57974, 59678, 210691, 212276; route aspa 50224 providers 6939, 15353, 26930, 34465, 37988, 50104, 52025, 52210, 59920, 60841, 210475, 400304; route aspa 50391 providers 6939, 20473, 48070; route aspa 50555 providers 970; route aspa 51019 providers 6939, 34549, 34927, 52025, 207841; route aspa 51396 providers 6939, 30823, 35133, 44066, 44592, 49581, 60223, 64457, 203446, 214497, 214995, 215436; route aspa 52025 providers 174, 835, 906, 917, 924, 1299, 3257, 6204, 6939, 7720, 8860, 12186, 18041, 20473, 21700, 21738, 25369, 29802, 32097, 34549, 34927, 35133, 35661, 36369, 37988, 39409, 47787, 48070, 48605, 50917, 51519, 52210, 56655, 57695, 61138, 64289, 197216, 199545, 208453, 209022, 209533, 394177, 396998, 397423, 400304, 400587; route aspa 52210 providers 174, 835, 6939, 52025, 62513, 210667; route aspa 54148 providers 835, 924, 6939, 20473, 21738, 34927, 37988, 47272, 50917, 53616, 53667, 207841, 209022, 209735; route aspa 54218 providers 917, 16509, 35487, 37988, 53667, 57196, 59678; route aspa 56762 providers 47689; route aspa 57984 providers 8283, 48112, 206763; route aspa 59678 providers 6939, 34927, 54218, 55081; route aspa 60223 providers 945, 49581; route aspa 60431 providers 34927, 41495, 50917; route aspa 60841 providers 30456, 400304; route aspa 149301 providers 20473, 61138; route aspa 151642 providers 20473, 61138; route aspa 198136 providers 0; route aspa 199310 providers 44324, 134835, 138997, 139317, 202662, 204844, 212895, 215828; route aspa 199376 providers 47311, 61112, 150249, 151544, 199762, 209533, 215379; route aspa 199762 providers 945, 6939, 8849, 15353, 34927, 44817, 47311, 48605, 140731, 150249; route aspa 200242 providers 835, 6939, 21738, 34465, 34927, 52025, 52041, 59678, 60841, 208453, 210475; route aspa 200351 providers 34927, 47272, 209022, 210475; route aspa 200454 providers 174, 6424, 6939, 9186, 12186; route aspa 202076 providers 207960; route aspa 202359 providers 30740, 33920, 41495; route aspa 202881 providers 205329; route aspa 203236 providers 20473, 44324, 53667, 53808, 200105, 201217, 203314, 213856; route aspa 203619 providers 200454; route aspa 203843 providers 6939, 20473, 53667; route aspa 204857 providers 50224, 59920, 60841, 400304; route aspa 204931 providers 34927, 44103, 207656; route aspa 205329 providers 945, 983, 6939, 7720, 8894, 9409, 20473, 34927, 41051, 131657, 134823, 151364; route aspa 205603 providers 38008, 38074, 59105; route aspa 205663 providers 20473, 61138; route aspa 205789 providers 200242, 207960; route aspa 205848 providers 1299, 6939, 34549, 34927, 52025, 209022; route aspa 207487 providers 20473; route aspa 207841 providers 6939, 137409; route aspa 207960 providers 6939, 20473, 34854, 34927, 136620, 202359, 207968; route aspa 209735 providers 6939, 207841; route aspa 210561 providers 207960; route aspa 212068 providers 6939, 13237, 62240, 207960; route aspa 212245 providers 917, 57695, 212068; route aspa 212516 providers 3204, 6939, 41720; route aspa 212934 providers 835, 6939, 34927, 52210, 53667, 61138, 62513, 209533, 210667; route aspa 213915 providers 215147, 215828; route aspa 214498 providers 16276, 207841; route aspa 215085 providers 35133, 42093, 52025; route aspa 215131 providers 8283, 34927, 212477; route aspa 215147 providers 34927, 41108, 47263, 207252, 213915, 215828; route aspa 215368 providers 207841; route aspa 215436 providers 6762, 6939, 51396, 60223; route aspa 215664 providers 1299, 3204, 6939, 34549, 41720, 56382, 203446, 212508; route aspa 215778 providers 8772, 29632, 39249, 41051, 207656, 209533; route aspa 215828 providers 6204, 6939, 8772, 29390, 29632, 34465, 34927, 39249, 41051, 44592, 48752, 50917, 51019, 51202, 58057, 62403, 152726, 197071, 199524, 203686, 207656, 209533, 210464, 211358, 215147, 216324, 216360, 393577; route aspa 215849 providers 215828; route aspa 216107 providers 924, 6939, 16509, 20473, 21738, 34927, 63473, 209022, 211588; route aspa 216265 providers 202673, 215051; route aspa 216311 providers 6939, 13852, 20473, 34927, 52025; route aspa 267386 providers 6939, 25933, 28220, 28649, 267613; route aspa 270470 providers 53062; route aspa 393577 providers 1299, 6939, 32097, 40676, 137409; route aspa 401111 providers 1012, 2497, 17676; route aspa 401507 providers 53356, 212477; }

-- Maria Matejka (she/her) | BIRD Team Leader | CZ.NIC, z.s.p.o.